Keep if it preserves your Deathmantle bonus while you assemble the next set; replace tier pieces together.
Feet
Shadowmaster's BootsBiS
Black Temple — Mother Shahraz
Edgewalker Longboots
Karazhan — Moroes
Use to recover hit from this slot; it has 13 more hit rating before gems than Shadowmaster's Boots.
Boots of Effortless Striking
Serpentshrine Cavern — The Lurker Below
Keep for agility and attack power if your hit and expertise remain sufficient after the swap.
Ring 1
Stormrage Signet RingBiS
Black Temple — Illidan Stormrage
Band of Devastation
Black Temple — trash drop
Use for haste and attack power when you can afford the hit or expertise lost from your current ring.
Unstoppable Aggressor's Ring
Black Temple — Gurtogg Bloodboil
Use for strength and crit when you can cover any hit or expertise lost from this slot.
Band of the Eternal Champion
Reputation — The Scale of the Sands (Exalted)
Keep for agility and attack power if your hit and expertise remain sufficient after the swap.
Ring 2
Band of DevastationBiS
Black Temple — trash drop
Ring of Lethality
Serpentshrine Cavern — Hydross the Unstable
Use to recover hit from this slot; it has 19 more hit rating before gems than Band of Devastation.
Ring of Deceitful Intent
Black Temple — Shade of Akama
Use to recover hit from this slot; it has 19 more hit rating before gems than Band of Devastation.
Violet Signet of the Master Assassin
Reputation — The Violet Eye (Exalted)
Use to recover hit from this slot; it has 25 more hit rating before gems than Band of Devastation.
Trinket 1
Bloodlust BroochBiS
Badge of Justice — G'eras, Shattrath
Tsunami Talisman
Serpentshrine Cavern — Leotheras the Blind
Keep this when its hit and crit fit your set and you can keep attacking through the attack-power proc.
Dragonspine Trophy
Gruul's Lair — Gruul the Dragonkiller
Use for sustained physical damage when you can keep attacking through the haste procs.
Trinket 2
Madness of the BetrayerBiS
Black Temple — High Nethermancer Zerevor
Bloodlust Brooch
Badge of Justice — G'eras, Shattrath
Use when you want attack power on demand for a planned damage window. Change the other slot too if it already holds this item; only one copy can be equipped.
Ashtongue Talisman of Lethality
Reputation — Ashtongue Deathsworn (Exalted)
Use when you can maintain frequent finishers and benefit from the resulting crit buff.
Main hand
Blade of InfamyBiS
Hyjal Summit — Anetheron
Vengeful Gladiator's Slicer
Season 3 arena reward — available September 1
Season 3 option, available September 1. A weapon option if you already earn arena points; compare the full weapon pairing before buying.
Talon of Azshara
Serpentshrine Cavern — Morogrim Tidewalker
Use when it matches your weapon-specialization talents; compare the complete pair before changing either hand.
Shard of Azzinoth
Black Temple — Illidan Stormrage
Use for a dagger build; compare both weapon slots and your poison setup together.
Off hand
Blade of SavageryBiS
Black Temple — Mother Shahraz
Vengeful Gladiator's Quickblade
Season 3 arena reward — available September 1
Season 3 option, available September 1. A weapon option if you already earn arena points; compare the full weapon pairing before buying.
Tracker's Blade
Hyjal Summit — Rage Winterchill
Use when it matches your weapon-specialization talents; compare the complete pair before changing either hand.
Ranged
Arcanite Steam-PistolBiS
Tempest Keep — Al'ar
Twisted Blades of Zarak
Black Temple — Teron Gorefiend
Use when you need a thrown weapon for Deadly Throw while keeping useful agility and crit.
Barrel-Blade Longrifle
World boss — Doomwalker
Use the two sockets to tune your melee stats. The gun’s own damage does not improve your melee attacks.
Sunfury Bow of the Phoenix
Karazhan — Prince Malchezaar
Keep for agility and attack power if your hit and expertise remain sufficient after the swap.